I don’t know when exactly it started, but somewhere between too many rushed subway mornings and hungover Sundays, I became obsessed with breakfast sandwiches in New York City.
Not the Instagrammable kind that’s all hype and no heart—but the ones that hit.
The ones that keep you full until 3 p.m., make your day better before it even starts, and remind you why NYC has the best damn food culture in the world.
Over the years, I’ve eaten my way through corner bodegas, high-end brunch spots, and everything in between.
Some sandwiches were good, a few were forgettable—but a handful? Unforgettable.
So I put together this list of 10 of the best breakfast sandwiches in NYC, covering everything from greasy bodega classics to refined, chef-driven creations.
No fluff here—just honest takes, solid food, and a whole lot of bacon, egg, and cheese.
1. Golden Diner – Chinatown Egg & Cheese Sando (Chinatown)
Golden Diner had been on my radar for months, and when I finally got a seat at this cozy spot tucked near the Manhattan Bridge, I knew I was in for something special.
The Chinatown Egg & Cheese Sando is unlike any egg sandwich I’ve ever had.
First off, it’s served on a scallion sesame milk bun—slightly sweet, soft but with a chew, and completely unique to anything you’d find at a standard deli.
The eggs are perfectly soft-scrambled, almost custardy, and topped with a thick, golden-brown hashbrown and American cheese.
- Price: ~$8
- Add-ons: You can get it with bacon or sausage for a few bucks more.
- Pro tip: Pair it with their Thai tea or matcha latte—it balances the richness beautifully.
2. Tompkins Square Bagels – BEC on an Everything Bagel (East Village)
If you’re craving a no-nonsense, straight-up killer bacon, egg, and cheese, Tompkins Square Bagels is essential.
I went on a weekday morning and still had to wait 20 minutes—it was worth every second. The bagel is massive, freshly made, with a perfect balance of chew and crust.
The bacon is crispy, the eggs are fluffy, and the cheese melts into every bite. It’s messy, it’s hot, it’s everything a NYC breakfast should be.
- Price: ~$7.50
- Menu variety: Dozens of bagel flavors, spreads, and sandwich customizations.
- Vibe: Expect a crowd and zero pretense. Just great food.
3. Win Son Bakery – Scallion Pancake Bacon, Egg & Cheese (Williamsburg)
Win Son Bakery takes Taiwanese-American comfort food and elevates it most creatively.
When I bit into their scallion pancake BEC, I felt like I had discovered something sacred. The flaky, crisp pancake replaces the bun entirely and adds a garlicky punch.
Their thick-cut bacon adds umami and crunch, and the egg is cooked just right—soft but not runny.
- Price: ~$9
- Pro tip: Order a side of their mochi doughnuts or soy milk coffee.
- Wait time: Usually a line, especially on weekends, but it moves fast.
4. Le Crocodile – PEC (Pancetta, Egg, Cheese) (Williamsburg)
View this post on Instagram
If you’re in the mood for a fancier take, Le Crocodile inside the Wythe Hotel offers a breakfast sandwich that’s borderline luxurious.
I went there on a quiet weekday morning and sat at the bar. The PEC sandwich is built on a house-made English muffin that’s buttery and flaky, almost like a biscuit.
The pancetta is crispy and salty, perfectly layered with a soft egg and sharp cheese. This sandwich is smaller in size, but high in richness and flavor.
You feel like you’re being taken care of, even if it’s just breakfast.
- Price: ~$13
- Pro tip: Go early and pair it with one of their fresh-squeezed juices or espresso drinks.
5. Don Juan Deli & Grocery – Classic BEC (Lower East Side)
@zuckersbagels Classic for a reason. We can’t get enough of a #BEC 🤝 #baconeggandcheese #bagels ♬ original sound – childhood charts
Sometimes you just need a sandwich that feels like home. Don Juan Deli is my go-to bodega spot for a classic BEC.
There’s no fuss. You order at the counter, watch them slap it together on the griddle, and five minutes later, you’re holding a greasy brown paper bag that smells like heaven.
The roll is soft, the eggs are cooked fresh, the bacon is crispy—not rubbery—and the cheese is gooey.
I sat on a stoop across the street with my coffee, and for those ten minutes, life was simple and good.
- Price: ~$5.50
- Extras: Add hot sauce or ketchup for free; sausage or double meat costs extra.
- Hours: Open 24/7.
6. O.H.S. Mini Market – Hearty BEC (Williamsburg)
I stopped by on a rainy morning, ordered a bacon, egg, and cheese on a hero roll, and ended up with a sandwich big enough to split with someone (though I didn’t).
The portions are massive, the bacon is generous, and everything tastes like it was made with actual love, not just speed.
- Price: ~$6
- Pro tip: Ask them to toast the roll—it makes a huge difference.
- Atmosphere: Classic NYC no-frills corner store vibes.
7. Sarge’s Deli – BEC on a Poppy Seed Bun (Murray Hill)
View this post on Instagram
Sarge’s has been around forever, and it shows in all the best ways.
The staff knows what they’re doing. Their BEC comes on a seeded bun that’s crispy on the outside and fluffy inside, holding in just the right amount of grease without falling apart.
The bacon is crisped to perfection, and the sandwich stays hot longer than most, probably thanks to the density of the bread.
- Price: ~$8
- Perk: It’s 24/7, so you can satisfy a 3 a.m. BEC craving.
- Ambience: Classic NYC Jewish deli meets diner.
8. Sunny and Annie’s Gourmet Deli – Creative BECs (East Village)
Sunny and Annie’s is where I go when I want something familiar, but with a twist. Their menu reads like a novel—sandwiches named after politicians, celebrities, and movies.
Their BECs go beyond bacon, egg, and cheese. One version I had included avocado, tomato, and sriracha mayo on a sesame hero—it was phenomenal.
The egg was just runny enough, the bacon crispy, and the layers balanced in flavor and texture.
- Price: ~$7–9 depending on customizations
- Must try: The “John Kerry” or “P.H.O. Real” breakfast remix.
- Open: 24/7.
9. Court Street Grocers – White Cheddar BEC on Muffin (Carroll Gardens)
Court Street Grocers offers a small but mighty breakfast menu. I went in expecting another average sandwich and was blown away.
The English muffin is toasted to golden perfection, and instead of the usual yellow cheese, they use aged white cheddar that melts smoothly and adds a sharp bite.
The bacon is thick-cut and well-seasoned.
- Price: ~$9
- Pro tip: Order ahead online to skip the wait.
- Location note: Small shop with limited seating—take it to go.
10. Frankel’s Delicatessen – Deli-Style BEC (Greenpoint)
@sergelato Frankel’s Deli: 8.9/10 & $50.75 ✡️ Food: 9.3/10 Quality: 9.1/10 Service: N/A Price: 8.3/10 OVERALL: 8.9/10 631 Manhattan Ave, Brooklyn, NY 112222 #frankelsdeli #brooklyndeli #brooklynfoood #brooklyn ♬ original sound – sergelato
Frankel’s is what happens when Jewish deli meets breakfast sandwich genius. Their BEC comes with a serious amount of bacon and high-quality eggs served on a fresh-baked roll or bagel.
I added caramelized onions, and it changed the whole flavor profile—sweet, salty, cheesy, and just greasy enough.
The place gets packed fast, so go early or prepare to wait.
- Price: ~$9
- Perks: Kosher-style, deli-quality meats, fast service.
- Vibe: Busy but efficient, with lots of local regulars.
Conclusion
At the end of the day, breakfast sandwiches in New York are more than just a meal—they’re a city tradition.
Whether it’s a $5 bodega BEC wrapped in foil and handed through a bulletproof window, or a $13 pancetta creation served on fine china at a boutique hotel, they all tell a story.
Every spot on this list brought something memorable to the table: unique bread, creative flavor combos, perfectly cooked eggs, or just that irreplaceable “New York energy.”
From the vibrant stalls of Brooklyn’s best food markets to the hidden gems on street corners, New York’s sandwich culture thrives on variety and authenticity.
These are the kinds of sandwiches that make you miss the city when you’re gone, and make you fall in love with it all over again when you’re here.
I’ve tasted plenty, and I know there are more out there—but these ten? These are the ones I’ll go back to. Again and again.
